Thursday, September 3, 2009

Towelhead

Towelhead is a sort of ‘Lolita meets Metilda’ with Alan Ball’s dark humor laced throughout. Jasira is a half-Lebanese, half-Caucasian girl who’s come of age and has discovered her sexuality. Many of the males in the movie have also discovered her sexuality. Her divorced parents are both neurotics and are more interested in their own selfish needs than in their daughter’s best interests.

The story pushes unspeakable ideas to the mental brink, where we know we are getting into uncomfortable territory and squirming, but sells it as not that far-fetched. When the man next door discovers that Jasira likes looking at his Playboy mags while babysitting his son, the scene is set for a series of events that leads to him sexually abusing her. In the final scene of this sequence, Jasira is complicit in her own abuse. Our jaws might drop at this concept, as in Lolita, but considering her lack of parental guidance coupled with her sexual discovery, it is not too difficult to see that for Jasira boundaries take a while to learn. Ball has an interesting view on just such experiences from his own life in this interview.

Ball’s dark humor is apparent in the quirky characters and their actions, as well as some embarrassing and repulsive scenes. Jasira’s mother, Gail, is so wrapped up in her own needs for companionship that she sends Jasira to live with her father when she discovers that her boyfriend has helped Jasira shave in a bathing suit. She tells Jasira that it is all her fault for not understanding how to act properly around a male. Some months later, Gail wants Jasira back because she split with her boyfriend and is ‘all alone’. When Jasira declines, Gail has a melt-down that is so infantile that one cannot help but laugh at her.

Jasira’s father, Rifat, is a humorous contradiction. He is always on edge and Ball depicts this well when virtually every time the doorbell rings Rifat says, ‘Oh, jeeze, what is it NOW!’ Yet, he is so intent on keeping up appearances and being a good suburbanite, that he takes a deep breath and greets the person at the door with sickening politeness. The flagpole war between Rifat and the neighbor at the start of the Gulf War are hilarious statements on suburban competition and conformity. One of my favorite dialogues in the movie follows. Gail has come to visit Jasira and her father at his house for Christmas and has just arrived:

Gail: Hey, what's with the flag?
Rifat: Oh, I'm supporting the war.
Gail: I thought you were protesting it.
Rifat: I'm protesting one aspect of the war and supporting another aspect. See, the mark of intelligence, Gail, is having the capacity of holding two conflicting ideas in your head at one time.

I will save the repulsive and embarrassing scenes for those who want to see the movie, but Variety states that “many scenes are too preposterous to be realistic.” Perhaps, but with elements of American Beauty and Six Feet Under, the comic relief from these scenes, while offbeat, helps us to get through the more jaw-dropping scenes of Towelhead that we might otherwise not be able to digest.

16 comments:

  1. I'd have to say that Ebert missed Ball's point. He should listen to the interview. Ball isn't simply bringing the topic of sexual abuse to the fore, but challenging our notions of victim and abuser, showing the messiness of emotions and situations.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I hope you don't mind me reviewing a not-so-new movie. Being a working mom, lots of movies pass me by on the big screen.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I went back a read Varieties review again. I must agree with one point...Ball takes on too many issues in the movie and it a bit distracting, but I thought the rest of the review a bit harsh.

    One thing that strikes me is that neither Ebert nor Variety mention the uplifting resolution at the end of the movie. Perhaps they were too busy focusing on how disgusted they were with the main themes.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am very intrigued. I didn't know it was Alan Ball, knowing that makes me want to see it.

    OSU did a series of one-act plays by Alan Ball one year, it was fun, but his world view gets kind of annoying in large doses. Yes, I get it, everyone is a jerk and were all going to die, ooh....how cynical.

    Of course those were his earlier years, I think he's gotten better by making the characters more like-able. Six Feet Under was great, and True Blood has become one of my favorite guilty pleasures.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow, I wouldn't have guessed that about Ball based on the interview...well, the death part, yeah, but not the everyone-is-a-jerk part.

    I love Six Feet Under even though I haven't seen all the seasons. Haven't seen True Blood yet, but hear that it is great. Ball talks about True Blood in that interview as well.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yeah, True Blood is a guilty guilty pleasure. . . Anyway, nice review.

    ReplyDelete
  7. To be fair, a lot of plays written in the nineties have major asshole protagonists. It was the style at the time, let's call it the Niel Labute effect.

    In Balls films and shows the characters are sometimes caricatures, like the wife in American Beauty. He's gotten pretty good at finding different dimensions in them.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks, C. E. Bailey.

    Caricatures...yes. The parents in Towelhead surely are.

    BTW,thanks for the Frida and Diego link. Very nice!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I just saw it, it was pretty bleak for a good portion. I like your analogy of Matilda meets Lolita. It was pretty apt, of course instead of a crazy headmistress who throws children, we get a charming pederast.
    The rest of the world seems bleak. Jasira has to get tampons and razors from the black boy everyone seems to want her to stay away from. She just stares passively at everything reacting through most of the thing.
    There is some redemption at the end, but before the responsible adults make and appearance Jasira is a pretty alienated figure. Everyone either hates her or wants to screw her.
    I will write more later.

    ReplyDelete
  10. You don't sound too thrilled with the movie. I was definitely seeing it through a lens of what Alan Ball described in his interview, so I was looking for that particular bent on it; namely, the idea that she wasn't ruined by her experience with the pedophile.

    I didn't think the black boy was out to simply screw her...part of his motivation to be sure, but he liked her, maybe even loved her. Then, yes, there were the helpful, sane neighbors.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I admire the film, but I don't like it, if that makes sense. After watching it, I could say, 'yes that was a good film.'

    It's like, it was good, now let's never speak of it again.

    But speak about it we must. As that is really the point, we must speak about it.
    I admire the film, the acting was good, the writing was good, the direction was good, even the lighting was interesting. Sometimes a little to dark, it sometimes seemed like all the light was on the outside, just making out tangible shapes of the darkness within, which is appropriate and purposeful even while it makes my eyes strain.

    I liked what Alan Ball said, like him I also identified with the main protagonist. I liked what he said about how all the characters are people, and complex. Real jerks, in many cases, but like I said before, he is good at finding more complexities in the caricatures, to the point where they resemble real people. Life is painful and messy, so there it is.

    I suppose I was waiting for a payoff, an emotional catharsis that never came for me. The blow out at the dinner near the climax is intense, but it almost borders on melodramatic, without getting far enough into it. The experience is a little dry.

    Another movie about ramifications of pedophilia, Mysterious Skin, was also ambiguous in its themes, but the finale few minutes left me sobbing uncontrollably. This movie left me a little more hopeful than when it started, but there was not enough release after being subjected to such pain.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The interview was really fascinating. I liked what he said about not wanting to be a victim, and was intrigued by his thoughts about how our culture makes a fetish out of victim-hood.

    So yes, ultimately, the movie is one of triumph in how the girl is not destroyed. I would have loved to see more off that. I need more evidence that she learned how to assert herself after spending a good portion of the movie staring at passively everything with a pained expression on her face.

    The best finale moment is the exchange between her and her boyfriend in the schoolyard, where she claims her own blood. That was the one moment that made it alright for me. Learning things about ourselves makes pain bearable.

    Also interesting were the fantasies that centered around the Playboy. The women speak directly to the camera, with the fuzzy lens, that obscures and airbrushes the subject. The subject becomes the object.

    This is echoed in a fascinating and disturbing scene where Jasira has a revelation inside glamor shots.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Mysterious Skin, however, is probably more concerned about the 'ramifications of pedophilia,' and not overcoming.
    Towelhead tells a different story, and it is an intriguing one. It was effective.

    ReplyDelete
  14. ...but I wouldn't watch it again.

    ReplyDelete
  15. "I admire the film, but I don't like it, if that makes sense."

    Yes, that makes sense. I REALLY felt that way when I read Lolita. The writing was so fantastic, but the story was just so disturbing. I will never read it again.

    "I liked what Alan Ball said, like him I also identified with the main protagonist.'

    Count me in as well.

    I really liked Ball's interview too. I remember hearing the beginning, when he was talking about First Blood, I was bored because all I was getting out of it was a vampire series. Then he started talking about Towelhead and what his experiences were and how he viewed what had happened and I was all ears. I had to see the movie.

    I did find the Playboy fantasies interesting and they reminded me of Six Feet Under.

    ReplyDelete